: Walsh played the older Arthur Dales (replacing Darrin McGavin, who fell ill during filming), a choice that received mixed reviews from some purists but was generally seen as a quirky, effective addition to the framing tale. Production Context
: The episode is noted for using its sci-fi premise as a metaphor for friendship, tolerance, and the racial barriers of the 1940s.
The X-Files episode is widely regarded by fans and critics as a heartwarming, sentimental masterpiece and one of the best standalone episodes of the entire series . Written and directed by David Duchovny in his directorial debut, the story centers on Josh Exley, an alien who falls in love with baseball and plays in the Negro Leagues in 1940s New Mexico. Critical Consensus [S6E19] The Unnatural
: Reviewers on IMDb praise the episode for its romantic and nostalgic atmosphere, noting that Duchovny's passion for the sport shines through every frame.
: Outlets like the Vancouver Sun have labeled the story "heartbreaking," particularly the tragic but sweet relationship between the alien Exley and young Arthur Dales. : Walsh played the older Arthur Dales (replacing
: His performance as Josh Exley was highly acclaimed, with critics calling it "terrific" and "charismatic".
: Critics from The A.V. Club note that while the internal logic is "fuzzy," the episode's "fairy tale" charm and willingness to experiment with the show's format make it a triumph. Guest Star Highlights Written and directed by David Duchovny in his
: The closing scene, where Mulder teaches Scully how to bat on a deserted baseball diamond, is frequently cited as one of the most charming and enduring "shipper" moments in the show's history.